246 Tasting Notes

65

Sipdown.. finally! I know this goes against the general opinion of this tea, but I just don’t find it to be anything to write home about. Honestly, I was disappointed when I first tried this and still even now because I am a lover of all things vanilla and this doesn’t fit the bill. Although the description says vanilla in aroma and taste, it is absolutely not authentic. Not Tahitian, not Madagascar/Bourbon, and not Mexican vanilla either. I would say after slowly working through 4oz, that the closest I can come to is a sugar cookie type blend with some artificial vanilla flavoring.

Sipdown.. finally! I know this goes against the general opinion of this tea, but I just don’t find it to be anything to write home about. Honestly, I was disappointed when I first tried this and still even now because I am a lover of all things vanilla and this doesn’t fit the bill. Although the description says vanilla in aroma and taste, it is absolutely not authentic. Not Tahitian, not Madagascar/Bourbon, and not Mexican vanilla either. I would say after slowly working through 4oz, that the closest I can come to is a sugar cookie type blend with some artificial vanilla flavoring.For what it is worth, my husband actually likes this, but he is not all about the vanilla like I am. He just likes having a sugar-sweet black for breakfast sometimes. Sadly, there are few teas I’ve tried that actually taste vanilla, but GO is my current go-to. Significantly more pricey ($12.50/oz) than the H&S vanilla ($1.75/oz), but actually utilizes real vanilla beans. I can’t afford to drink GO daily like I could with this one, but it makes for a very fulfilling treat when I need my vanilla fix.

Flavors: Artificial, Cookie, Sugar, Sweet

Preparation
Boiling 4 min, 0 sec 2 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML
Nightshifter

I don’t know why information above is duplicated. It isn’t on my submission page or edit page. I posted in the bug thread about it- sorry!

Dustin

I’m with ya on this one. It underwhelms me as well.

Tealizzy

Have you tried Tippy’s Not So Vanilla yet? Very much a Madagascar vanilla bean tea!

Shae

What is the difference between this and the Vanilla Comoro? They sound very similar, if not the same, to me. I like that one a lot, but also get cookie more than vanilla.

Nightshifter

I haven’t tried Tippy’s- when I looked before there weren’t very many reviews, but I’m glad to hear it is good! I will be checking it out again today. :)

I think the difference between Vanilla Black and Vanilla Comoro is that the latter is decaf. I personally don’t have any interest in trying it after finding Vanilla Black unsatisfactory. Maybe they will reformulate it at some point to make it more vanilla and less cookie/artificial. I wouldn’t mind if the price went up some, I just love good vanilla and their base is no problem, just the flavoring.

ashmanra

To me, Vanilla Comoro has more intense caramel flavor. Since it is their decaf Ceylon base, which has nice flavor and isn’t too weak like some decaf, I think they added a little extra “oomph” to make up for it being decaf. That said, there is a huge difference to me between the sachets and the loose leaf, the loose leaf being full of bits of vanilla bean seeds and specks. Loose is much more flavorful in Vanilla Comoro. Sachets were just okay by comparison.

Nightshifter

Interesting! Is there an ingredient list on the tin or anything? I can’t find it on their website for Vanilla Comoro, but Vanilla Black positively didn’t have any vanilla bean parts- just flavoring agents added to the loose leaf.

Shae

I had completely forgotten about the Vanilla Comoro being decaf. That’s definitely a difference! I do enjoy it, but you’re probably right in that if you don’t like this one you likely won’t like the Vanilla Comoro either. You said that GO is your go-to vanilla tea – which company is this? I’m not familiar and now I’m curious. I have the Tippy’s Not So Vanilla on my list, but I would be curious to check into that one as well.

Nightshifter

GO= Golden Orchid from Whispering Pines tea. It is the best vanilla black I’ve had so far (and I’ve been on a quest for a few years now). I have to try Tippy’s also now, though. :)

Shae

Oh! Gotcha. That one’s on my list too. :)

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

95

Thank you so much to Angel at TeaVivre for the samples!

Dry: Fine, airy, short tea leaves with significant golden pekoe that carry the aroma of baked sweet potatoes and fragrant grass hay. Do you ever take a whiff of dry loose leaf and have the knowledge that you will enjoy it before your first sip? That happened this morning for sure. The pekoe is bright and lovely even against the stainless infuser backdrop.

Steeped: Brewed Western style that produces a deep red-brown clear liquor. The thin leaves unfurl and become milk-chocolate colored in the infuser. The scent is malty-sweet with a honey aroma that develops as you keep inhaling.

Taste: This tea is very tasty without being overpowering. Delicate notes of malt and sweet potatoes that are very smooth and light on the tongue. This is not a heavy or thick tea, but rather one that gently envelops the senses with a sweet presence. I saw that some people detected astringency, but steeped at 1 minute, there is absolutely nothing brisk or bitter about it. I think this would be an excellent choice to help someone new to fall in love with Chinese black teas.

Flavors: Malt, Smooth, Sweet, Sweet Potatoes

Preparation
195 °F / 90 °C 1 min, 0 sec 2 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML
caile

Love this one! :)

Nightshifter

It’s so good! I forgot to mention that it resteeps very well, too.

Tealizzy

Yes, that’s a good one!

Jude

So true about the newbies falling in love with this one. I was seduced, myself.

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

84

Tasty for what it is and very pretty with the blue and white stars, gold candy bits, and mini marshmallows, but I prefer S’mores from DT if I get to chose a dessert tea. I enjoy this from time to time and it does have a caramel echo, but next time I order I hope to get a GINORMOUS bag of S’mores instead.

Flavors: Caramel, Smooth, Sugar, Sweet

Preparation
Boiling 4 min, 0 sec 1 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

80
drank SoHo Blend by Harney & Sons
246 tasting notes

Blerg. I’ve totally fallen out of love with this one. I originally was very impressed, but I don’t know if it hasn’t aged well or if my palette is more refined, but I am counting the number of steeps until I can move on to something else from H & S that I like better, like Florence. At least I still have some Paris to work on also, which is one of their best flavored blends, IMHO.

Flavors: Cocoa, Coconut, Malt

Preparation
Boiling 4 min, 0 sec 1 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

94

Oh this is a perfect tea for a cold and rainy afternoon. Soft, warm, a hint of buttery osmanthus and of course the gentle, inconspicuous milk note. The green of the unfurling leaves matches the few mossy things left outside in the fog that haven’t been swept away in the coming of winter. The aroma of the brewed tea is comforting and restful. I think I’ll have another steep or three (and it will be a re-order for sure). Stay warm, friends!

Flavors: Butter, Milk, Osmanthus

Preparation
Boiling 1 min, 0 sec 2 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML
DeliriumsFrogs

Ooooh! I loved your tasting note.

Nightshifter

Thank you! :)

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

79

I finally finished the 4oz tin I had of this today. I honestly won’t miss it much. Since I’ve tried more flavorful Keemun teas from other vendors (I really like Keemun from Teavivre in particular), I don’t feel the need to keep this around. This tastes kind of like toast on steroids, but isn’t particularly full-bodied or complex to my palette. It was a good and inexpensive starter breakfast tea, but I’d prefer Scottish Morn any day of the week.

Flavors: Toast

Preparation
Boiling 4 min, 0 sec 2 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML
Veronica

I like Scottish Morn, too. It’s a nice breakfast tea.

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

88

I spent all afternoon with this one yesterday and it is my first pu-erh in probably 2 years or so. The only other experiences I’ve had were from David’s and a local store-bought one, both of which I PASSIONATELY DESPISED. Why would I want to drink stinky fish-dirt tea?!

Just wanted to give a background on my lack of good experiences with this kind of tea. The thing is, I love trying new things and I didn’t get how so many people love pu-erh when I absolutely hated it. I decided to give it another go. And this time purchase one that I had carefully screened for offensive fishy notes.

The dry loose (no cake on this one) leaves are tightly rolled, dried, almost powdery-looking. They are dark with lighter golden-brown hues mixed in. I don’t know how other pu-erh teas feel, but this one was heavier in my hand than the loose leaf black teas I am used to. It smelled a bit like a blend of dates and earth, but not in a moldy way if that helps (sorry!).

I brewed it with my lovely and delicate TeaVivre gaiwan and the steeped tea is a deep red-brown clear liquor. It is very aromatic with more of the prominent dates and earth fragrance- almost reminds me of piles of leaves after the rain.

The initial flavour is straight up walnut (with the shell and all) blended with a brown sugar sweetness. It still has the earthy background, but it makes it feel thick and full-bodied on the tongue instead of like a dessert. I followed the brewing directions exactly for this with 30/15/30/45/2 min/5 min and each time I was able to enjoy the walnut, brown sugar, earth combo, though it became notably weaker towards the end. I didn’t give this a higher rating only because I was desperately looking for the vanilla/cream/camphor notes described on the WP website and I didn’t find them. That said, I still really enjoyed it. Next time I am going to try Western style brewing and see if I can find those missing notes. As many of you know, I love true vanilla and even the faintest taste would be wonderful in a tea that is already a pleasant way to spend a rainy afternoon.

TLDR version: I used to think I hated pu-erh. Now I don’t. This one tastes like walnuts, brown sugar, and earth. :)

Flavors: Brown Sugar, Dates, Earth, Walnut

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 0 min, 30 sec 3 g 3 OZ / 90 ML
Fjellrev

I’m glad you had a pleasant experience! Count me in as still being in the Pu-erh Tastes Like Stinky Fish-Dirt club, which colloborates with the Smoky Woodsy Forest Covered in Moss club at times too.

looseTman

Congrats on your first enjoyable shou! Welcome to the dark side! There’s no return!
Missing notes: What type of water are you using?

Nightshifter

Haha, thank you! I used Dasani purified water because my city water smells like a pool.

Whispering Pines Tea Company

Nightshifter, if I looked up your order correctly, you’re an hour away from one of the most healing springs in the world. I’d recommend getting a big canister for water and filling up from there. It should produce absolutely phenomenal tea. :-)

http://www.findaspring.com/locations/north-america/usa/indian-springs-indian-springs-state-park-georgia/

looseTman

“I used Dasani purified water because my city water smells like a pool.”

To remove chlorine you may wish to consider the following.
Per Consumer Reports:
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/water-filters/buying-guide.htm?pn=0

Carafe water filters:
- Clear2O CWS100A – 93 pts
http://www.clear2o.com/
http://www.amazon.com/Applica-Clear-Water-Pitcher-CWS100A/dp/B00189XOEG
- ZeroWater ZP-010 10-cup and ZD-013 8-cup Pitchers – 70 pts
The Gravitea filter wasn’t tested by CR.

Another convenient option to consider:
Faucet-mounted water filters
- Culligan FM-15A or FM-25 – 80 pts.
http://www.culligan-store.com/product_detail.asp?T1=CUL+FM%2D25&.
http://www.amazon.com/Culligan-FM-25-Faucet-Mount-Filter/dp/B0064MKTE0
- Pur FM-3700B – 77 pts.
– Brita Base On Tap OPFF-100 – 75 pts.

See also:
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/water-filters.htm
http://pressroom.consumerreports.org/pressroom/2010/04/cr-finds-10-recommended-water-filters-that-can-replace-bottled-water-.html

For those who have a refrigerator with a built-in water dispenser, most include a replaceable water filter cartridge:
http://www.filtersfast.com/Refrigerator-Water-Filters-cat.asp
http://www.freshwatersystems.com/c-453-refrigerator-filters.aspx

Whole-house chlorine filter:
20-inch Single Canister Big Blue Radial Flow Carbon Whole House Filter – http://abundantflowwatersystems.com/

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

79

Another sipdown. I have a number of teas that I am finishing off, but most I don’t plan to re-order (like this one). While I do think this tea hits the buttered rum flavoring pretty spot-on, the coconut ultimately throws the whole thing off. I’ve made real buttered rum before and while it is ridiculously rich and has the sharp edge from the rum that this tea manages to pull off, I just can’t do the sweet and tropical note. I do love that it is organic.. but can we just drop the coconut please?

David’s is really hit-or-miss for me much of the time. I love some like Pumpkin Chai, but many others come across as artificial or strange to my palate. There seems to be random coconut in many of their flavored blends. I wish I could order tiny samples since there aren’t any shops within driving distance. Maybe someday!

Flavors: Butter, Coconut, Rum

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

50
drank Toasted Walnut by DAVIDsTEA
246 tasting notes

Sipdown. I would describe this one as “meh.” I think I don’t like the base very much for the flavoring. This sencha is pretty oceanic/seaweedy and it is kind of a bizarre cross with very sweet things like dried pineapple and candy brittle. It isn’t terrible, but it actually doesn’t taste exceptionally nutty either now that I am thinking about it. Maybe misnamed and a questionable combo both.

Flavors: Caramel, Fruity, Ocean Air, Seaweed, Sweet

Preparation
180 °F / 82 °C 3 min, 0 sec 1 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

90

Comforting is a word I would use to describe this tea. I made a 64oz pot of it and my husband and I have been sipping the lightly-honeyed cocoa maltiness for a few steeps now. I am totally hoping to order more now that I’ve found my groove with wee snail yums, but I really, really, really want to get Rivendell with my next order, too. I wanted to order it with both of my last two orders and its been out of stock forever. Since my favorite flavored green from Butiki is gone now, I need a vanilla or creamy replacement. Any suggestions?
For the Redditors-TL;DR: I like this tea. And I want Rivendell or something like it really bad.

Tealizzy

I think Brenden said he was going to restock Rivendell about mid-month, so you might not have to wait long!

Nightshifter

I hope so! Brenden had told me it was supposed to be back in stock mid-month last month. Fingers crossed!

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

Profile

Bio

I am a registered nurse that worked night shift for years on a catastrophic injury unit. I just started day shift and life is good! Tea is a simple pleasure in a complicated world.

Location

Georgia, USA

Following These People

Moderator Tools

Mark as Spammer