Hide

Welcome to Steepster, an online tea community.

Write a tea journal, see what others are drinking and get recommendations from people you trust. or Learn More

Creme Earl Grey from Element Tea
40

Element Tea included this is a sample in my recent (first, last, and never again) order from them. Sad they are going out of business, but yay for cheap tea. I ordered three real teas, and you would think I’d try them first, but nope. When I saw this was an included sample, I got really excited, because I almost bought this, but didn’t.

I’ve been searching for a tolerable Earl Grey…. and this is not it, unfortunately. I steeped this for 3 minutes with boiling water, and at first I thought it was too bitter… until I realized it was just very citrus-y. Almost like a grapefruit peel. Ick. I think that’s the Oil of Bergamot coming in that I’m not a big fan of. I was hoping to taste some creaminess, but all I get is that citrus taste. Not good :( .. It does have an interesting smell to it.

I decided to cut this with some skim milk, and in doing so, it’s a lot better. BUT, I still want a tea that I can drink straight, so having to put milk in it to make it tolerable shouldn’t really be necessary. I don’t mind a tea where the milk enhances the flavor, but no point in buying a tea that I can only drink under certain conditions if there are others I can drink straight- right?

Second infusion at 3 minutes: Brewed this again at 3 minutes, and the second infusion is not nearly as strong – which is good. It tastes less citrus-y and more like black tea. I just think I’m not a big Earl Grey fan, and may never be. How sad :(

People who liked this

Michelle
DaisyChubb
RachanaC (Rachel)-iHeartTeas
LiberTEAS
Angrboda
Kittenna
Azzrian
Will Work For Tea

Comments

Michelle
Michelle 2012-07-01 13:52:25 -0400

I’m the same way. I’ve never found an EG that’s tolerable without milk. Although the EGC from David’s Tea is really, really smooth.

Babble
Babble 2012-07-01 14:41:02 -0400

Hmm.. I’ll have to look into that. Too bad David’s Tea doesn’t really do samplers :(

Michelle
Michelle 2012-07-01 14:44:18 -0400

I’ll send you a bit if you want, I have half a tin sitting around.

Alphakitty
Alphakitty 2012-07-01 15:20:01 -0400

Upton’s EGC is also very smooth and only lightly beramot-y, plus they sell samples!

Babble
Babble 2012-07-01 21:49:30 -0400

@Michelle – Oooh, that would be awesome! Thanks :-D

@Alphakitty – I’ve considered getting Upton’s. Is this the creamy one or just the straight?

Alphakitty
Alphakitty 2012-07-01 22:42:04 -0400

The Creme Vanilla is very lightly citrusy—I’ve never tried their standard EG, but if you’re looking for a subtle bergamot taste the creme vanilla is about as light as you can get while still being an earl grey. I have 8oz of it, so if you’d like a sample PM me ^^

Michelle
Michelle 2012-07-01 23:16:38 -0400

@Rachel – I’ll stick it in the post tomorrow!

Babble
Babble 2012-07-02 01:07:19 -0400

Awesome! Thanks!! :-D

mrawlins2
mrawlins2 2012-07-02 11:45:44 -0400

Harney and Son’s Earl Grey Supreme is pretty light, but still tasty. I would definitely recommend it.

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

Profile

Bio

So the short story is, a few years ago I was VERY MUCH into tea. And then a lot of things happened, and I got out of tea for a while. And now, I’m back.

To me, tea is the missing puzzle piece for my healthy lifestyle. When I drink tea I am encouraged to eat healthy and be active. I drink tea because I simply enjoy the taste, but the health aspects are just an added bonus.

I love all types of teas, although greens and oolongs tend to be my favorite. I also love a good herbal.

Unless otherwise stated, I drink my teas straight. To brew I either use my ingenuiTEA or T-Sac (for teas that don’t expand much). One of these days I might break down and buy a Breville, but I’m trying to resist..

I’m kinda strict when rating my teas. I rarely give a tea above a 95. Teas that I really like I keep in the 95-85 category. I’ve yet to give a tea 100 yet. So, if you see a tea about 95, that means I thought it was an amazing tea!

Location

Florida, United States

Following These People

Azzrian
Azzrian

Most of my reviews w...

Michelle
Michelle

Michelle, 19. Colleg...

Fong Mong Tea
Fong Mong Tea

Fong Mong Tea Corp. ...

KeenTeaThyme
KeenTeaThyme

Hello fellow tea fan...

Jenn
Jenn

I'm an animal loving...

Kittenna
Kittenna

I have always been a...

LiberTEAS
LiberTEAS

I am obsessed with t...

52teas
52teas

Hand-crafted Artisan...

DaisyChubb
DaisyChubb

You can call me Dais...

darby
darby

VERDANT TEA lover!!!...

Bonnie
Bonnie

%{color:green}Colora...

ColoradoKate
ColoradoKate

I won't lie - I like...

Ninavampi
Ninavampi

I love tea and have ...

Alphakitty
Alphakitty

Tea has always been ...

RachanaC (Rachel)-iHeartTeas
RachanaC (Rachel)-iHeartTeas

A lover & provider o...

Dylan Oxford
Dylan Oxford

My fiancé and I are ...

See More