Never having had the famed Butter Beer from the Wizarding World of Harry Potter, I imagine Butter Beer to taste somewhat like buttered rum – which I will admit I am no connoisseur. This tea has a very strong sweet and caramel scent. I did not taste these notes too prominently while drinking this tea. It was not overly sweet to me, but I was expecting the flavors to be more prominent. I am going to play with the steep times when I brew it again. Definitely drinkable, but not something I would order regularly. By no means do I think it is a bad tea, just not a stellar tea or one that will become a daily drinker. At this point, I would recommend it, and am going to experiment a bit with this blend to see if I can coax out more of the flavors.