The best Earl Grey loose-leaf tea brand

Help me decide. Give some examples please.

23 Replies

I have Harney & Sons EG and EG Superior samples being shipped this week. They are new to me.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Finisterre said

I really enjoy the earl grey from Postcard Teas and think its a good clean crisp tasting Earl Grey that works best without milk http://www.postcardteas.com/site/product/gianfrancos-earl-grey/

Rob said

Absolutely agreed, Postcard Tea Earl Grey is the best I have tasted.

ashmanra said

I love Postcard but haven’t tried their Earl. Thanks for the recommendation. i will have to amend that!

Login or sign up to post a message.

Harney’s Earl Grey Supreme is one of my favorites. The Tea Centre’s Earl Grey Special is another, but you’ll have to get it shipped from Sweden: http://www.theteacentre.se/p/earl-grey-special/996

Adagio has a few decent Earl Grey versions as well.

Login or sign up to post a message.

I read about Harney & Sons. People said it is superior tasting Earl Grey. Unfortunately my country does not import any product from this brand.

Gitana said

What tea brands are available to you? That will affect recommendations!

If you can get Twinings Earl Grey it is a well respected brand and is quite highly rated. For many people Twinings is the taste they use to judge all other Earl Grey teas.

“The best” is more difficult because everyone likes something different.

One good quality tea that might be available to you is Tayors of Harrogate. They are a U.K. brand and are probably everywhere in Europe. Their Earl Grey is very smooth and a little floral in flavor.

Ahmad is another brand you might have available. They use a different tea base than Twinings or Tayors. Their teas are generally economical and more “robust”. Their Aromatic Earl Grey has a lot of Bergamot flavor but some people say it is too strong.

I would try as many brands as you can. Beg samples from friends!

@Gitana
Thank you for that comprehensive reply.

Well, Twinings are very popular in my country although they are one of the most expensive commercial teas available. I tried blue one. It has got some extra fruits which IMO overpower Earl Grey scent. It tastes more like typical fruity tea, than traditional Earl Grey tea I am familiar with. However I do not like very strong bergamot scents. I prefer ones that are subtle, natural, on the light side. There are many Earl Greys which give you this artificial perfume afertaste… yuck.

Tayors of Harrogate are unavailable in my country. Only shipping. I find Ahmad teas way too robust. I drink tea to relax and it plain, without sugar and milk, so I prefer mild teas.

I am interested in Twinings Earl Grey, the yellow one. Did you drink it? Is the scent strong or rather subtle? How about tea strenght?

Login or sign up to post a message.

Gitana said

Honestly, I haven’t tried Twinings in years and I don’t recall much about it. I am in Mexico now and herbal tisanes are more popular here. Black tea is very hard to find!
Twinings list their international blend Earl Grey as “light” in flavor so it might be worth trying. You can shorten steep times to keep the flavors light too.
I have Ahmad that I bought in the U.S. and I mix it with lighter tea to tone down all that flavor. That might be worth trying too!

Login or sign up to post a message.

mahjongfan said

Earl Grey from Harney & Sons is by far the best,they have three versions, all of which are great. My favorite is the Earl Grey Supreme.

What’s the third EG? I noticed that the new Murder On the Orient Express tea is a black/oolong/bergamot.

mahjongfan said

Gingerbread, it is Earl Grey, Earl Grey Imperial and Earl Grey Supreme, the Imperial only comes in sackets (I think). I like the regular too, the Imperial is good, but I prefer loose leaf to sackets for everyday use.

Login or sign up to post a message.

@Gitana
I followed your advice and bought Twinings Earl Grey (yellow tin). I have not tried it yet, but smells nice. It has very light aroma. I will try it tomorrow for my breakfast.

Gitana said

Great! Let me know if you like it. I think I might buy some next time I am in the U.S.

@Gitana
I tried it today. Well although I find it too weak and mild, it’s quite interesting tea.
Full description: https://steepster.com/teas/twinings-of-london/80413-earl-grey-tea?post=372835

Gitana said

I am sorry Twinings was not your ultimate tea. You might try mixing it with another tea. Sometimes mixing will yield the best tea because you choose the tastes you want.

@Gitana
No problem. Today I bought Earl Grey from Sir Adalbert’s Tea company. Have you ever heard about them? It seems like they operate mainly in Poland, but I guess like many tea importers they are a part of a bigger importing group. However, tea tastes great. In dry leaves bergamot scent is quite strong but pleasant and natural. However in infusion it becomes more mellow. For me it is what I am looking for in a cup of Earl Grey.
I added it today: https://steepster.com/teas/sir-adalberts-tea/83139-earl-grey#

@Gitana
Have you tried this tea?

Gitana said

No. It is not available in the US that I know of. Maybe if I come to Poland you can serve me some one day!

Login or sign up to post a message.

Did you try Earl Grey from Sir Adalbert’s Tea?
https://steepster.com/teas/sir-adalberts-tea/83139-earl-grey#

Login or sign up to post a message.

Earl Grey is my favorite tea..The best I’ve ever had, hand down, by far (it’s just soo good I can’t even express) is from Westholme Tea!!

Login or sign up to post a message.

ashmanra said

Earl Grey Supreme from Harney and Sons is excellent. Murder on the Orient Express is great, too, for Earl Grey lovers.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Login or sign up to leave a comment.