55

2025 Steepster Advent Swap: Day 2

What a throwback! I haven’t had good ol’ Sugar Cookie Sleigh Ride in at least a decade, possibly more like 15 years. Man, I used to love all the Celestial Seasonings holiday blends, especially this one, Nutcracker Sweet, and Candy Cane Lane. <3

Today I’m not getting much flavor, to be honest, even though I used two tea bags. It’s a little bit musty and a little bit sweet, with some very faint vanilla sugar notes and a distinct chalkiness.

So fun to have this again!

Flavors: Chalky, Musty, Sweet, Vanilla

AJRimmer

I’ll always love this one! But I do dress it up quite a lot to make it tasty.

Kelmishka

Good call! Michelle kindly included quite a few tea bags, so I’ll have to play with the remaining ones. :)

gmathis

This is the first Christmas season in a long time I haven’t had any of this under my roof. Probably wouldn’t be too hard to fix that ;)

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

People who liked this

Comments

AJRimmer

I’ll always love this one! But I do dress it up quite a lot to make it tasty.

Kelmishka

Good call! Michelle kindly included quite a few tea bags, so I’ll have to play with the remaining ones. :)

gmathis

This is the first Christmas season in a long time I haven’t had any of this under my roof. Probably wouldn’t be too hard to fix that ;)

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

Profile

Bio

(she/her)

I was an anxious child who didn’t like change, so when my parents flew across the country for my grandfather’s wedding and left us kids with my aunt and uncle, I was a nervous wreck. Our first night at their house was tough. I couldn’t sleep, so I got up and padded into the kitchen, where my aunt was puttering around. She could tell I was distressed and offered to make me a cup of tea. It was just Celestial Seasonings’ peppermint tea, but it was exactly what I needed. The tea itself, the comfort it represented, the ritual of making it… I was enchanted. I’ve loved tea ever since.

I’m partial to strong, intense flavors and prefer loose-leaf to bagged, but I also appreciate the convenience of bags and sachets. I mostly drink my tea straight but once in a blue moon I’ll add a little plant-based milk, generally oat.

I live in Maryland, USA, with my partner, three dogs, and one cat. I’ve actually been a Steepster reader for years and years, but only started posting in late 2021. :)

When I’m not drinking tea (or sometimes WHILE I’m drinking tea!) I’m reading, rewatching comfort shows, going for a run, knitting, embroidering, hiking, or puttering in the garden. You can find me on Instagram at @kelmishka. (My account is private, but feel free to send a request!)

Favorite ingredients, flavors, etc.

Maple (all-time fave flavor!), vanilla, caramel, and all things dessert-y

Jasmine, lavender, violet, and most floral flavors

Most spices, although I go through phases and sometimes get bored of generic-feeling winter spice blends

Most fruity flavors

Matcha and other vegetal flavors

Not-so-favorite ingredients, flavors, etc.

Bergamot (…although it’s been growing on me lately!)

Hibiscus

Overly artificial flavors (banana, coconut, mango)

Overly herbacious blends, although this varies!

Stevia, monkfruit, and other sugar-alternative sweeteners — blech

Chocolate — it’s hard to get it right in tea, though I love real chocolate!

Animal products, including honey (long-time vegan checking in!)

My ratings

90-100: The best! Will almost definitely repurchase.

75-90: Really good, and potentially worthy of a restock.

60-75: Decent, if not terribly memorable.

50-60: In the “meh” range, but possibly for personal taste reasons.

35-50: I’m not a fan, and this is not very good tea.

20-35: Varying degrees of bad.

1-20: Actively bad. Like really bad. I can’t imagine anyone disagreeing.

Location

Maryland, USA

Following These People

Moderator Tools

Mark as Spammer